I'm just back from Lebanon (that would be Lebanon, New Hampshire) where I heard a performance of Puccini's Madame Butterfly. If you pay no mind to the ridiculous racist orientalist anti-American story, it's a pretty good opera. The orchestra, though small, was excellent and the singers top-notch. The music is a little on the overwrought side, and the garish emotional display makes Dostoevsky seem in comparison like drawing-room comedy. It's a sad, dated story. While Emma Bovary found the solution to her problem in arsenic, Anna Karenina in the locomotive and Edna Pontellier in the water, Cio-cio-san elects the knife -- more evidence, if more is needed, for women's paucity of choices in the grand old days. But great melodies, no question. The opera crowd was, as usual, a little on the geriatric side -- and as a consequence I felt quite youthful bounding up to the balcony. At breakfast the next day, a friend admitted to being moved by Cio-cio-san's suffering. "Did you cry," I asked. His reply: "I'm not saying."
Post a comment
Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.
Your Information
(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)
Comments